Thursday, June 15, 2017 by Tracey Watson
Little Cole Hartman was dealt a bad hand right from the beginning. Born with fragile X syndrome, he had both physical and mental disabilities. When his mom died while he was just a toddler, he was adopted by Jeremy Hartman and his wife Elizabeth. Then, when he was just 8 years old, his dad came in from mowing the lawn of his Castaic, California, home one day, to find Cole with his head in a running washing machine. It is believed that he may have had his head in the water for as long as 25 minutes.
Though paramedics were able to get Cole’s heart beating again, he remained in a coma and had to be put on a ventilator. When the medical team at Ronald Reagan UCLA Medical Center informed Mr. and Mrs. Hartman that their son, though not brain dead, would never regain normal neurological function or wake up, they made the difficult decision to take Cole off life support and donate his organs. He died 23 minutes after being removed from the ventilator.
That was four years ago. Now, the district attorney’s office and homicide detectives with the LAPD have launched an investigation to determine whether anesthesiologist Dr. Judith Brill may have given little Cole a dose of fentanyl high enough to be fatal to hasten his death and facilitate organ transplantation.
Since Cole wasn’t brain dead, his organs could only be retrieved after his heart stopped beating on its own. This type of donation is known as donation after cardiac death (DCD), and puts major pressure on the transplant team since organs start deteriorating as soon as the ventilator is switched off. [RELATED: Accused murderer receives liver organ transplant while others die.]
No charges have been brought at this time, and Dr. Brill’s lawyer, Mark Werksman, calls the allegations “factually wrong and patently offensive.”
In an email to the Los Angeles Times, Mr. Werksman said, “[Brill’s] only concern was to assure that this child, who had drowned and was never going to recover, would not suffer any pain following the removal of life support.”
That’s not what Denise Bertone, a coroner’s investigator specializing in the deaths of children, believes. Bertone fought for four years to get Cole’s death investigated after becoming suspicious that fentanyl administered by Dr. Brill had caused his death. She begged then-chief medical examiner/coroner Dr. Mark Fajardo to test the boy’s blood, but he refused. The cause of death was listed as near-drowning.
According to a lawsuit subsequently filed by Bertone, Dr. Fajardo only agreed to test the boy’s blood after repeated emails and complaints from her. Though the results showed fentanyl in Cole’s system, Fajardo refused to change the cause of death.
When Fajardo left his position, Bertone approached the acting chief medical examiner, Dr. Lakshmanan Sathyavagiswaran, about reopening the case, and he agreed. A pediatric toxicologist determined that fentanyl “was responsible for the death of this patient,” and that the dose was “not consistent with a therapeutic dose for the management of pain and discomfort.”
The death certificate was subsequently changed, and fentanyl toxicity was added as a cause of death. Law enforcement was asked to investigate. [RELATED: Stay up-to-date at Medicine.news]
Bertone alleges that her supervisors moved her off investigating the deaths of children because she refused to back down and continued to push for Cole’s death to be investigated.
Meanwhile, Dr. Brill is deeply troubled by the allegations levied against her. She is highly respected as an expert in the treatment of gravely ill children, and was involved in writing the state’s guidelines for pediatric critical care. She also did extensive humanitarian work with children in Asia, Africa and Latin America.